Coated nonstick pans make cleaning up a lot easier, and this 3-set unit from Granite ware is one of the top units in the category. In the box, you get a roasting pan, grill rack and baking tray, which works together to form one handy broiler pan.

Finished with PFOA and PTFE-free porcelain enamel, the Granite Ware 3-set unit distributes, retains, and distributes heat over its surface quickly. So, you can expect nice chars and crunchy crusts when you heat your food on it.

While the perforated tray is excellent for cooking fish and vegetables, you’ll find the rack useful for grilling and the roasting pan perfect for cooking Lasagna. You can also use the roasting pan as the drip tray when broiling.

When we found this unit, one question rushed in our minds. Why get three pans for grilling, broiling, and baking when you can go for this 3-set Granite Ware unit?

The Granite Ware 3-set is perhaps the most versatile pan that we’ve ever come across. We figured that you could use it on a barbecue or in your oven, which is pretty cool. But the best part is that anything you cook on it turns out great.

Although the combo unit is safe to use, we found that the surface was a lot like glass, which made it prone to cracking and warping. Drop it, and your broiler pan could be gone!

If you want a versatile unit, consider adding the Granite Ware 3-set to your list.

The second broiler pan to make this list is this 2-piece (pan and grid) Whirlpool unit. You can use it separately or as a combo for broiling your favorite foods. Made from a stainless-steel core and forcefield with porcelain, this pan is one to heat food up quickly.

The surface can easily fit medium to large-sized slabs of meat and several rows of vegetables. So, you can use it to broil for a large family at once. As a plus, it’s also reasonably easy to clean and helpful in preventing splatter and smoke while broiling.

The slots on the Whirlpool 4396923 not only allow air to circulate your food but also drain grease from it. You can use this broiler pan for cooking your food to perfection.

There are several nice things about this unit we can say off the top of our heads, and previous customers would confirm that the Whirlpool 4396923 is a great pan for broiling. We like that it’s compatible with different ovens, even with its large cooking area.

One thing you should note about this pan is that it will burn your fat drippings if you use it at blazing temperatures. So, keep the temperature on a low setting when using this Whirlpool broiler pan.

If you can find a way to prevent the coatings from chipping, then you’d love using the Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pan.

Third, on our list of the top broiler pans in the market and our best for build is this P&P Chef Toaster unit. It’s made from stainless steel and doesn’t contain any toxic or unsafe coating. So, there’s no chance that it will change the taste of anything you put on its cooking surface.

As a small-sized broiler pan, you should be able to perfectly fit this unit in regular ovens easily. Cleaning the product is a walk in the park, thanks to its non-stickiness. But the best part is that you can cook anything from bacon, meat, veggies, fish, Lasagna and bread on its surface.

If you’re looking to start broiling and eating light, this is one of the top rated broiler pans. You might not find a more compact pan, which is a blessing (compatible with many ovens, easy to maneuver) and a curse (works for small meals only).

Something the manufacturer won’t tell you is that you should clean this pan’s surface with a dish towel before use to get the particles and dust away.

The single life has some perks, one of which is eating cheap by broiling your meals at home. The P&P Chef Toaster oven broiler rack and tray allows us to do just that!

General Electric (GE), a well-known brand for cookware and household utensils, needs no introduction.

This GE broiler pan has two pieces: a pan and a tray. The tray is serrated with venting slots, which helps to produce well-broiled meals. And with its nonstick coating, cleaning this unit is a breeze.

You can use the lower piece of the GE WB48X10056 as a drip tray or bake mouth-watery meals. As a large-sized broiler pan, this unit can fit large food items easily.

What’s there to not like about this broiler pan? It cooks food evenly, is large enough to fit several rows of food at a time and made by a recognized brand.

Apart from its sharp edges, one issue we couldn’t wrap our heads around was the chipped coatings that several customers complained about. It’s no fun seeing particles on food just before taking a bite, so don’t scratch too hard when cleaning.

But besides this setback, the unit is a great one for broiling different food quantities.

If you have a small family, then chances are that you’ll love using this product to broil food. Made by a reputable brand, the Nord Ware 42210 broiler pan works on regular and toaster ovens. The unit has two pieces: a rack and a tray.

Thankfully, this one is made from nonstick coatings and is excellent for cooking different types of food.

The Nordic Ware is small-sized and can fit even the smallest of ovens. Little wonder customers refer to it as the best non stick broiler pan out there.

No rule says your broiler pan must be finished with black coatings. So, it is quite exciting to find a gold-colored pan like the Nord Ware 42210. You can use it in ovens as long as you don’t exceed the 450°F limit.

The nonstick coating comes off when you overheat your food, so moderate heat settings is the way to go with this unit. Metal utensils and abrasive cleaners are a no-no for it.

Overall, we think the Nord Ware 42210 has almost everything anyone can ask for in a broiler pan.

When we think of a medium-sized stainless-steel broiler pan, the Norpro 273 Roast/Broiler set readily comes to mind. It’s a sturdy two-piece unit with a perforated top tray and a bottom tray with a large grease-holding capacity. Like every other broiler pan out there, this unit is great for cooking steaks, well-spiced turkeys, fish, and even bread.

After broiling, you can wash this unit by hand or throw it in a dishwasher. When positioned properly, this unit can fit two pork loins in an oven.

We’re not big on completely stainless-steel units. So, we weren’t all so excited when we found this product until we used it.

Indeed, it isn’t the largest broiler pan out there, but it sure can easily fit in most regular ovens. The heat distribution on both trays was remarkable, so we figured that we might as well start using it for baking food items. Just be careful with the edges.

For its price, the Norpro 273 Broiler pan meets and exceeds our expectations. If you need a durable and easy to clean unit, then consider getting it!

If you need a premium quality broiler pan to make different types of food, this should be one of the first units to come to mind. A V-shaped rack comes with the unit, and the bottom pan has two riveted handles at the sides.

From its size, you can tell that this broiler pan can take massive foods. So, you placing a whole turkey should be a breeze. Furthermore, the bottom piece heats up evenly, and you can get the char and browning you desire from broiling food.

There are not many flaws you can pick out from this unit, and most of what we found were positive reviews from previous customers. In terms of its size, there’s hardly any broiler pan that can go head to head with this unit. We confirmed the manufacturer’s claim that this unit can hold up to 25 lbs! Isn’t that cool?

The unit also doesn’t have hot spots and is excellent for broiling and roasting meat, fish, vegetables.

However, this top-notch feature has a downside. Our tip is that you should check your oven to ensure it can fit this unit before you go ahead and get it. But asides that, you’ll agree that it is perhaps the premier broiler pan out there and worth every cent you’d pay for it when you start using it.

Another broiler pan that’s one of the best in the market is the Wilton 11x 7-inch nonstick set. It’s an averaged sized, and that’s great for broiling hamburgers, meat, fish, and veggies in the oven. Unlike other grill pans we’ve seen, the two-piece set is kept close together and not elevated.

The top tray is coated with a porcelain enamel and has diagonal ridges across its area.

You might not get a better medium-sized broiler pan set that this Wilton 11 x 7-inch unit. It’s versatile, durable, sturdily designed, easy to clean. Our favorite feature is its 5-year warranty because we can get a bit clumsy when using it.

On the downside, we can’t reason out why the bottom tray is not nonstick. It’s best to stick to handwashing it even though the manufacturer claims it is dishwasher-safe. Otherwise, we reckon that it’s a nice unit to have and perhaps the best nonstick broiler pan we’ve ever come across.

Coming in ninth in our list is this Frigidaire 5304442087. It’s just as good as all other units we’ve reviewed, and as you would expect, the set has two trays: a top one with slots and a bottom piece you can use as a drip tray.

Compatibility is a problem with many broiler pans, but not this unit. It works on not only Frigidaire ovens but several other regular ovens. The blue finish on the broiler pan set is eye-catching, and an excellent way to add color to your kitchen.

You should be able to place two rows of small-sized meat pieces on the top tray easily.

If you want the best unit for broiling, then we recommend this unit. We used it to broil hamburgers, chicken, steak, vegetables, and several other meals, and we absolutely loved it!

We were pretty disappointed that the blue finish chipped easily. So, don’t try using metal utensils on this unit. Overall, you can’t fault a lot of things about this broiler pan; little wonder customers call it the pre-eminent broiler pan for design.

Next, we have the Range Kleen BP106X two-piece broiler pan. The top tray has ridges and slots for food to pass through, and you can use the flat bottom to bake delicious cakes, bread, or French fries. Like any other porcelain enamel unit, this broiler pan combo set is easy to clean.

Let’s have a look at some things we like and don’t like about this broiler pan.

Versatile, perfect fit, and high heat retention: these are the words that come to mind when we look at this unit. It fits into different sink sizes and is one handy broiler for making meals for a couple. Potatoes, veggies, meat, fish, you name it! This broiler pan can take anything on.

In a nutshell, it is everything we want in a broiler pan and more. You should consider getting the Range Kleen BP106X broiler pan if you need to replace your top-notch unit.

Our final product on this list is the large nonstick Farberware broiler pan. It has riveted handles that make lifting and pulling it out of the oven smooth and safe.

In the box, you get a rack that works for grilling. But this broiler pan’s best feature is its warp resistance.

Overall, we recommend you can give this broiler pan a try if you want to enjoy well-broiled meals. Food doesn’t stick to the cooking surface, and it sure heats up quickly.

We searched extensively for drawbacks about the Farberware 57026 pan but could not find many, even from customer reviews. The product is excellent for broiling!

Nevertheless, we found that you still need to be careful when cleaning the cooking surface and back of the pan, if you don’t want the surface to peel.